Yes, I agree with that crux, never disagreed with it. I still think it was functionally democratic, it's not like the top controlled every aspect of society. Often times the elections with the most impact on your personal lives are the local elections, and that's where Workers did in fact have control.

Again, though, I've never argued for repeating the USSR. I just think that we can learn from what worked and what didn't to create a better system of leftist organization, and the fact that so much went right and so much went wrong is exceptionally useful data. We know what not to replicate democratically, and we know that guaranteeing Healthcare and education, and investing heavily in building residential plots and urbanization at the public level, does tremendous work in reducing poverty and homelessness.

At the end of the day, I'm NOT an ML, nor am I a USSR Stan. I'm a leftist, and more importantly I'm anti-tendency, and think each country will have a different path to worker liberation. As such, we should learn as much as possible from previous Socialist attempts and structures to create a better future.

Do you disagree with that notion?