this post was submitted on 28 Feb 2024
102 points (94.0% liked)
Technology
59589 readers
3148 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I don't understand Telegram, it just seems like Signal, but worse. Can someone explain to me what the purpose of Telegram is?
I’ve been a heavy Telegram user since around 2016. I’d say the main thing I love about it is their focus on user experience. Everything is always super fast, looks nice and feels smooth. They’re often pushing new features which is always cool to see.
Plus their iOS/macOS apps look native and aren’t web-based, so it’s a great replacement for iMessage.
At this point I’ve converted my whole family and friends and they all love it too!
For me:
Signal also has usernames now.
Yes, finally. But I would say a bit late to the party. And a privacy focused IM not thinking about this for years blows my mind.
It works, on every OS, seamlessly, for instant messaging (which is all I use it for).
I use multiple devices throughout the day, and all messages show up instantly on every device, while supporting file transfers, etc.
It just works.
Signal is like using SMS. The UI sucks. And no sync between devices. I appreciate what they're trying to do (which is why sync between devices is challenging), but I can't get anyone to use it anymore since they dropped SMS support.
Telegram banned me literally seconds after I registered, even before I could finish setting up my profile. Not once but twice weth two different numbers. Without any kinds of explanations as to why. I've contacted support multiple times but literally zero replies. People literally do drug businesses there, host pirated stuff and CSAM, that's somehow ok and me just registering is where they draw the line?
Can't say that about Signal. So as far as I'm concerned, yeah Signal is way better.
A good cross platform user friendly client goes a long way, especially having a good desktop version.
It's big in the furry fandom, weirdly enough. Not as much these days as it used to be, but still big enough.
Its better than signal in every aspect except privacy (still better than whatsapp in that and arguably a secure messaging app).
You didn't tell me how it's better in any way, and you told me that it's worse in a very very important way. So... why would I ever use it?
Sounds to me like Signal is still the best messaging app.
Its better because: It can sustain big public groups (upto 200k peoples), channels with unlimited subscribers, unlimited cloud storage (files upto 4gb, synced across devices), powerful bots, web apps, native crypto support, you can do pretty much anything within the app (literally a superapp), heaven for pirates, stickers, video calls, live streams, etc. unlimited devices could be signed up for one account, messages sync across devices, free with minimal ads, premium to get more features, completely run by users support and ad platform, no external entity involved. secret chats for end 2 end encryption chats and much more.
Telegram is more geared towards group communication. It has a much better group chat experience and a channel feature that lets you disseminate information in a single place without a discussion taking place. It is better at group communications in that it is more feature-rich.
If you’re doing is 1:1 messaging or have some small group chats with 2-3 friends you wouldn’t get much out of it over Signal.
I've heard Telegram is better for distributing Russian/right wing propaganda, so there is that...
It's not really "better" it just has an opt in social media feature (these channels)... There's no recommendation algorithm, it's not pushing anything, you have to explicitly seek these channels out.
It would be like subscribing to a Lemmy community except there's not even a "front page" feed, you have to explicitly search for it. Nobody accidentally is joining "Nazis R Us" or being subjected to their messaging.
Now is it helping these groups organize/spread information to their members... Maybe?
Telegram has a pretty relaxed moderation platform that basically is "don't call for violence, don't do illegal things, and we're generally okay with it"
Worth a read (from the founder) https://t.me/durov/230
nice argument comrade, "I've heard"
Its financially backed by the Kremlin.
edit: source
Atleast read the article before spreading misinformation 😮💨, telegram is completely funded by its users.
Dunno,
maybe
ther is
something
to it
also https://www.wired.com/story/the-kremlin-has-entered-the-chat/
Again bs
Shoes you can express your views freely on telegram, seems plus point to me
Russian/right wing
Hahahahahahahahahaba
Any app that depends on you forgetting about privacy is bound to make everything else shine so bright you forget that flaw
While the fact is privacy has been there top priority since starting, heck they even have e2ee chats. No data leaks report so far
It's like a shadier Discord/WhatsApp mashup. Founded by Russians now based in Cyprus, iirc, and funded (in part) by the Kremlin. So I guess don't write anything you don't want the siloviki to read.
https://www.wired.com/story/the-kremlin-has-entered-the-chat/
and
https://gulfnews.com/business/abu-dhabis-mubadala-says-it-brought-russias-rdif-into-telegram-bond-stake-1.1616586642665