this post was submitted on 30 Jan 2024
116 points (98.3% liked)
Framework Laptop Community
2654 readers
1 users here now
Related links:
- Framework website: https://frame.work/
- Official Framework Mastodon: https://fosstodon.org/@frameworkcomputer
Related communities:
- Buy it for life community: !buyitforlife@slrpnk.net
- Fairphone community: !fairphone@lemmy.ml
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I love the aesthetic design.
The whole conversation about ports misses the not-so-obvious point that the cartridge system saves the motherboard ports from destruction. This is extremely important for long-term use. Ports not only have limited cycle life but get killed by happenstances in life. Standard laptops lose ports over time. That can only be fixed by board replacement. On a Framework, it's $20 and a cartridge reload.
Then there's the cooling... A laptop with adequate cooling for its hardware... What is this this - the 2000s? With that kind of cooling capacity, this machine will last for a very long time.
This is so true! Whether it's the power port, a standard USB port, or your HDMI port, damaging it on a regular laptop can either be costly or impossible to fix without a full mobo replacement.
Looking back at all the laptops I've owned that needed to be replaced because repairs were either non-existent or too expensive, I realize that every single one of them could have been saved if they'd been Framework laptops.
I love my Framework 13, but when it comes time for my wife to replace her current laptop (a 17" Dell that's been a workhorse for over a decade), I'll be getting the Framework 16 and she'll have the 13. I don't think I could ever go with another brand after my experience.
The port in my old XPS 15 ~~can be~~ has been replaced in 10 minutes with a screwdriver, with a $5 replacement port. I honestly don't even love the laptop but I can't fault it's repairability.
My point is while this framework laptop is insanely cool, I don't think that repairability is as huge an advantage as it's made out to be. Beats a macbook I guess, but for a lot of mainstream laptops the only difference in repairability is needing a screwdriver set and I little more time (negligible imo since I only need to repair/upgrade maybe every 2-3 years. maybe)
You're lucky your XPS'es port is replaceable without a mainboard swap. Is this true for all ports?
Also the repairability comparison with mainstream machines lacks a crucial point. The availability of genuine parts and for reasonable prices. A Framework battery runs me about 60-70 bucks. A genuine battery for my ThinkPad has typically been closer to $150. If I could even find one.
Hold on, the battery's another thing I had to replace. Let me find how much I paid.
Edit: I paid a little less than $50 on eBay from ebl. They're a reputable seller, I bought rechargeable AAA's from them more than five years ago and they're still kicking
I have a ton of EBL batteries. And my reality was confirmed when Project Farm did a "one year later" follow-up, which confirmed what I was experiencing: EBL batteries are garbage. LOL
I haven't done any real tests so I guess I'll defer to you on that. It's been more than three years of daily use since installing the laptop battery though, so I'd say the fact that I haven't noticed a significant drop in battery life means that $50 is no less then a fair price.
Ok I just looked up oem, damn I'm cheap lol: https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-6-cell-97-wh-lithium-ion-replacement-battery-for-select-laptops/apd/gpm03/pc-accessories
No not all ports, just power and and auxilary, but I honestly can't recall a single time that I've lost a usb port.
Here's the (excellent) repair docs if you're interested: https://dl.dell.com/topicspdf/xps-15-9560-laptop_Setup-Guide_en-us.pdf
My old latitude from 2011 is similarly easy to repair, it's running a jellyfin server rn.
I've lost USB-A on a ThinkPad and a miniDP. The USB went from use, the miniDP got destroyed in an accident.