So, I was thinking that I joined Lemmy.World because Lemmy had more users than MBin. But today I was looking at https://mbin.cocopoops.com/ and started seeing MY posts. I knew Mbin could have different instances. I knew Lemmy could have different instances. And I knew they all federated together.

But I didn't know Mbin could federate with Lemmy. But I'm sure Lemmy/Mbin probably won't federate with Pixelfed, or Peertube.

Mbin, piefed, and Lemmy are essentially reddit replacements. So they should be in a circle. It doesn't matter how many users Mbin has, or piefed has, or Lemmy has. It matters how many the full circle of federated reddit replacements have. Because thats the true circle of users that you can interact with.

So what we need is a website that you enter an instance, and it tells you how big your circle would be on that platform, and a list of federated, and defederated instances with it.

So Lemmy.World would have a pretty high circle. While hexbear would have only itself, if I understand right.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] GlenRambo@jlai.lu 2 points 2 months ago (1 children)

I like the idea. In regards to lemmy and its instances (so I guess a smaller Scale to what your suggesting ... Though I still don't fully get the fediverse).

I did something similar when picking a Lemmy instance. What was the instance that had defederated others the least. There was a git page somewhere that listed them all.

On the flip side I've heard a notion that no one single instance should become the "main" instance. Probably with your suggestion new users would gravitate to the big circle. Thus making it the "default". But maybe it's different when looking outside of lemmy instances to the wider fediverse.

[–] Lost_My_Mind@lemmy.world 2 points 2 months ago (1 children)

I see things differently. I think there should be a few general use instances. The general use instances I think should be the "main" instances.

Then there should be specialty instances. Like a star trek instance, with several communities, each covering a different topic.

Or a baseball instance, with several instances, one for each team.

Or a H Jon Benjamin instance, with several communities, one for each project he's worked on. Maybe even have some peertube videos on stuff he's done.

Each general use instance, I can't imagine needing more than 10 of those would have a large amount of people.

Each specific subject instance would have lower population. But thats ok, because their main role isn't to host users. It's to host content. Whereas the general instances would mostly hoat content and be a link aggregator.

Of coarse.......none of that is how it's being applied so far. Right now it's an unorganized mess.

[–] rhythmisaprancer@moist.catsweat.com 2 points 2 months ago

Or a H Jon Benjamin instance

Haha hard to take that seriously 🙂 I'm down with that jazz