This is the classic, we want to control information so that only painful and tragic exit methods are known about by the general public.
I.e. Paternalistic gatekeeping suicide is a sin.
this post was submitted on 01 Jan 2024
102 points (90.5% liked)
Technology
59589 readers
2962 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
That assumes that the person was going to die regardless, while in reality lots of people can and do get the support that they need. This is different from medically assisted dying.
Hiding information doesn't help, but encouraging support and controlling the market for the poisons can help.
"Suicide is a sin" isn't the only reason we support those dealing with the issues, even if that might be the motivation of people in some places.
Helping people, yes
Giving people options, yes
Showing people a better way, yes
Removing options, gatekeeping
Restricting information, gatekeeping
Removing options, gatekeeping
There's some nuance here too
Say barriers on bridges and high areas that the public can access. It's removing an option yes, but it might be enough friction to stop the person till they can receive the help they need
I concede the benefit of barriers to prevent accidents, or to discourage people from jumping from this point right here. Delaying the impulse. We don't deny people the knowledge of gravity, and we don't legistate the removal of high places. If someone really wants to jump they have options, hiking to a cliff etc.
Let's say there is a magic pill, that is painless, no side effects, etc. let's say we made this available for people's pets in pain, but not for humans in pain. In this fictional universe the gatekeeping of "enough pain" to justify a dignified and self selected exit is a net evil. As long as a human has agency they should have a choice without officials gatekeeping their knowledge. (I.e. we shouldn't nanny adults)
I don't think the main point of the barriers is preventing suicide specifically, but safety in general. Preventing suicide is more of a bonus.
Yes. Let's burn all the books too in case someone does something bad with that knowledge. And ban everything but soft pillows from being sold in any store.
What a stupid fucking coroner.
Soft pillows could be used for smothering
We should ban everything besides whoopie cushions then; you could probably still smother someone with one but it’d be a lot funnier
Ban the pillows too. We’ll have to use heshen sacks full of straw instead
Oh no, not the fluffy cushion!
smothering
Yeah, a wooden board wouldn't work for that now would it?
She died as a martyr so we can have even more of that universal mass survelliance.
It was probably sodium nitrite. There's been an increasing number of people using it to exit as it's used in meat seasoning. In the UK you can only buy quite low concentration bulk packets.
The UK would try to ban nitrogen because it can be used to commit suicide. No more Guinness at the pub I guess.
No more balloons for your party either!
Early last year I was almost able to buy it in high concentration from apc pure, but did not have a good lie lined up when they asked me why I was purchasing it. Seems like it's no longer available, but I bet it can be got with some effort.
I hope you're doing okay now.
Feels like such a reach. I have no love for Amazon but what are they supposed to do here? Ask you at check out "Are you trying to commit suicide with these items?" Typing is most keywords for suicide and Google pops up with suicide prevention info on top screen already. People who want to do something will find a way.
I'm guessing that guy never heard about the Streisand Effect and the expression "if it bleeds, it leads"
This is the best summary I could come up with:
Google and Amazon must act after a British woman made a suicide pact with two people she met online and bought the poison that killed her on the internet, a coroner has said.
Chloe Macdermott, 43, died on 23 May 2021 after buying a lethal substance from the US on Amazon.
She had been struggling with her mental health for several years before she began researching ways to end her life on an online forum, an inquest at inner west London coroner’s court was told this month.
The coroner Paul Rogers recorded a conclusion of suicide and issued a prevention of future deaths report to Google and Amazon, saying he believes they have the power to prevent another similar tragedy.
Posts are made by users containing details of methods of suicide without any effective administration to remove such harmful content.”
The availability of the poison online and the ability of Britons to have it delivered from the US “without effective border and/or custom controls” was also a matter of concern, Rogers said.
The original article contains 411 words, the summary contains 172 words. Saved 58%. I'm a bot and I'm open source!
Grow the fuck up. What idiot coroner thinks that an individuals personal decision to end their life is literally anyone elses fucking responsibility?
Should have their license pulled for being this much of a fucking idiot.